docs/random/wtay/capsnego2 - imx-gstreamer - Git at Google


 the current capsnegotiation sucks and plainly doesn't work for queues.
 one of the reasons is that the core is trying to do too much, like
 being a mediator in the negotiation process. There is also way too much
 interaction between plugins. Plugins have to keep a lot of state too.

 The proposed method works by sending chains of caps instead, requiring
 a worst case of 2 interactions between plugins. The drawback is that
 a negotiating plugin has to do a bit more work, but in pactice this is
 not a real argument against the proposed method, as the actions it has
 to perform cannot be avoided. We will provide sufficient APIs to
 facilitate this.

 We are not going to send random chains of caps between plugins but we
 are going to filter them by using a new gst_caps_intersect() function
 that can find the common media types and properties between the plugins.
 The main idea is that the simple case should remain simple.

 We also introduce app specific filters that can be set while doing a
 pad connection.

 We proceed with a few use cases because they tend to explain the ideas
 better.


 use case 1
 ----------

 v4lsrc -> xvideosink

 no pad restrictions set on pad_connect
 v4lsrc can do many formats, so can xvideosink

 - v4lsrc request caps:

   width and height properties were set on v4lsrc so it provides them as hints.

   GstCaps *peercaps = gst_pad_request_caps (v4lsrc->srcpad,
                         GST_CAPS_NEW (
 			  "v4lsrc_srccaps",
 			  "video/raw",
 			    "width",    GST_PROPS_INT (352),
 			    "height",   GST_PROPS_INT (288)));

 - core fetches xvideosink caps. if xvideosink has a request_caps function,
   then the intersection of the hint, v4lsrcpad template caps and xvideosink
   sinkpad template are sent as input.
   If xvideosink has no request_caps function, the padtemplate
   caps of xvideosink are taken.
 - after intersect on both caps, peercaps equals:

   peercaps ==
     gst_caps_chain (
       GST_CAPS_NEW (
         "xvideosink_caps",
 	"video/raw",
           "format",       GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("YV12")),
           "width",        GST_PROPS_INT (352),
           "height",       GST_PROPS_INT (288)
       ),
       GST_CAPS_NEW (
         "xvideosink_caps",
 	"video/raw",
           "format",       GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("I420")),
           "width",        GST_PROPS_INT (352),
           "height",       GST_PROPS_INT (288)
       ),
       GST_CAPS_NEW (
         "xvideosink_caps",
 	"video/raw",
           "format",       GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("YUY2")),
           "width",        GST_PROPS_INT (352),
           "height",       GST_PROPS_INT (288)
       ),
       GST_CAPS_NEW (
         "xvideosink_caps",
 	"video/raw",
           "format",       GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("UYVY")),
           "width",        GST_PROPS_INT (352),
           "height",       GST_PROPS_INT (288)
       ),
       GST_CAPS_NEW (
         "xvideosink_caps",
 	"video/raw",
           "format",       GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("RGB ")),
           "bpp",          GST_PROPS_INT (16),
           "depth",        GST_PROPS_INT (16),
           "endianness",   GST_PROPS_INT (G_BYTE_ORDER),
           "red_mask",     GST_PROPS_INT (0xf800),
           "green_mask",   GST_PROPS_INT (0x07e0),
           "blue_mask",    GST_PROPS_INT (0x001f),
           "width",        GST_PROPS_INT (352),
           "height",       GST_PROPS_INT (288)
       )
     )

 - v4lsrc does:

    while (peercaps) {
      /* check if the caps can be used */
      if (caps_are_useful (peercaps)) {
        break;
      }
      ...

      peercaps = gst_caps_new (peercaps);
    }

    gst_pad_set_caps (v4lsrc->srcpad, peercaps);

 - core check compatibility with v4lsrc and xvideosink caps. if all goes well
   caps are set on the pads.

 - negotiation was more effective if v4lsrc provided srcpad caps since maybe
   YUY2 etc could be removed in the intersect (when v4lsrc doesn't support that
   format).


 use case 2
 ----------

 mpeg2dec -> colorspace -> xvideosink


 - mpeg2dec does:

   gst_pad_set_caps (mpeg2dec->srcpad,
                      GST_CAPS_NEW (
 		       "mpeg2dec_srccaps",
 		       "video/raw",
                          "format",   GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("I420")),
 		         "width",    GST_PROPS_INT (720),
 		         "height",   GST_PROPS_INT (480)
 		      )
 	           );

 - core checks compatibility with mpeg2dec srcpad caps and colorspace caps.
 - newcaps function of colorspace is called.
 - colorspace requests peer pad caps with the hint.
 - xvideosink doesn't have a request_caps function, the hint is ignored and
   the padtemplate caps are returned.
 - colorspace runs intersect on the two caps.
 - if the intersection is NULL, colorspace has to set up a conversion function.
     - runs through the list of caps, picking the first one for which a
       converter exists between the received caps and the target caps. set up
       the converter and set the target caps on the srcpad.
 - if the intersection is not NULL, set received caps on colorspace srcpad.


 use case 3
 ----------

 mpeg2dec -> queue -> colorspace -> queue -> xvideosink


 Same as use case 2, really. the queue just forwards the caps and the
 request caps.

 can we use a default implementation for this proxying? probably.
 for an element with no newcaps function or request_caps function, we can
 simply set the caps on all srcpads when a set_caps is performed, or we
 can request and intersect all srcpad caps when a peer element does
 request_caps. This will actually work for tee too, to some degree.


 use case 4
 ----------

 gst_pad_connect_caps (...),
 gst_element_connect_caps (v4lsrc, "src", xvideosink, "sink",
                            GST_CAPS_NEW (
 		             "app_caps",
 		             "video/raw",
                                "format",   GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("I420")),
 		               "width",    GST_PROPS_INT (352),
 		               "height",   GST_PROPS_INT (288)
 			   )
 			 );

 - as long as the connection is not broken, the caps are set as a filter to the
   to pads.

 - when v4lsrc requests pads, the intersection with the filter is also made.

 - v4lsrc has no other choice but to use I420.

 use case 5
 ----------

 mad -> osssink

 in this case, mad can both send "int" audio samples and "float" samples.

 - mad request_caps from osssink, sending the fixed properties as hints (rate,
   channels, ...)
 - osssink has a request_caps function, the core first makes the intersection
   between the hint and mad srcpad template. the core then does the intersection
   between osssink sinkpad template and sends this list to osssinks request_caps
   function. osssink can try this list (or whatever remains of it) and whatever
   works is sent back as the return value of the request_caps function.
 - mad receives the caps list, takes the top caps and does a pad_set_caps
 - osssink recieves the final caps on its new_caps function and configures the
   oss driver.


 use case 6
 ----------

 gsm -> audioscaler -> osssink

 Somebody sets some crazy low rate on the gsm srcpad (1000Hz).

 - audioscalers newcaps function is called.
 - audioscaler does a request_caps on its srcpad with the provided
   caps as a hint.
 - osssink tries the caps in the request_caps function (by opening the
   device, seeing that it doesn't support this rate at all...)
 - osssink tries to comply as closely with the rate and sends the
   intersection between its padtemplate caps and the findings (rate 8000Hz
   is possible).
 - audioscaler does the intersection between the caps list and the hint.
 - intersection == NULL, a converter is needed between the hint and
   the first caps of the request_caps list.
 - intersection != NULL, set those caps (== the hint).

	the current capsnegotiation sucks and plainly doesn't work for queues.
	one of the reasons is that the core is trying to do too much, like
	being a mediator in the negotiation process. There is also way too much
	interaction between plugins. Plugins have to keep a lot of state too.

	The proposed method works by sending chains of caps instead, requiring
	a worst case of 2 interactions between plugins. The drawback is that
	a negotiating plugin has to do a bit more work, but in pactice this is
	not a real argument against the proposed method, as the actions it has
	to perform cannot be avoided. We will provide sufficient APIs to
	facilitate this.

	We are not going to send random chains of caps between plugins but we
	are going to filter them by using a new gst_caps_intersect() function
	that can find the common media types and properties between the plugins.
	The main idea is that the simple case should remain simple.

	We also introduce app specific filters that can be set while doing a
	pad connection.

	We proceed with a few use cases because they tend to explain the ideas
	better.


	use case 1
	----------

	v4lsrc -> xvideosink

	no pad restrictions set on pad_connect
	v4lsrc can do many formats, so can xvideosink

	- v4lsrc request caps:

	width and height properties were set on v4lsrc so it provides them as hints.

	GstCaps *peercaps = gst_pad_request_caps (v4lsrc->srcpad,
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"v4lsrc_srccaps",
	"video/raw",
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (352),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (288)));

	- core fetches xvideosink caps. if xvideosink has a request_caps function,
	then the intersection of the hint, v4lsrcpad template caps and xvideosink
	sinkpad template are sent as input.
	If xvideosink has no request_caps function, the padtemplate
	caps of xvideosink are taken.
	- after intersect on both caps, peercaps equals:

	peercaps ==
	gst_caps_chain (
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"xvideosink_caps",
	"video/raw",
	"format", GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("YV12")),
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (352),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (288)
	),
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"xvideosink_caps",
	"video/raw",
	"format", GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("I420")),
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (352),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (288)
	),
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"xvideosink_caps",
	"video/raw",
	"format", GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("YUY2")),
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (352),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (288)
	),
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"xvideosink_caps",
	"video/raw",
	"format", GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("UYVY")),
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (352),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (288)
	),
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"xvideosink_caps",
	"video/raw",
	"format", GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("RGB ")),
	"bpp", GST_PROPS_INT (16),
	"depth", GST_PROPS_INT (16),
	"endianness", GST_PROPS_INT (G_BYTE_ORDER),
	"red_mask", GST_PROPS_INT (0xf800),
	"green_mask", GST_PROPS_INT (0x07e0),
	"blue_mask", GST_PROPS_INT (0x001f),
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (352),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (288)
	)
	)

	- v4lsrc does:

	while (peercaps) {
	/* check if the caps can be used */
	if (caps_are_useful (peercaps)) {
	break;
	}
	...

	peercaps = gst_caps_new (peercaps);
	}

	gst_pad_set_caps (v4lsrc->srcpad, peercaps);

	- core check compatibility with v4lsrc and xvideosink caps. if all goes well
	caps are set on the pads.

	- negotiation was more effective if v4lsrc provided srcpad caps since maybe
	YUY2 etc could be removed in the intersect (when v4lsrc doesn't support that
	format).


	use case 2
	----------

	mpeg2dec -> colorspace -> xvideosink


	- mpeg2dec does:

	gst_pad_set_caps (mpeg2dec->srcpad,
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"mpeg2dec_srccaps",
	"video/raw",
	"format", GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("I420")),
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (720),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (480)
	)
	);

	- core checks compatibility with mpeg2dec srcpad caps and colorspace caps.
	- newcaps function of colorspace is called.
	- colorspace requests peer pad caps with the hint.
	- xvideosink doesn't have a request_caps function, the hint is ignored and
	the padtemplate caps are returned.
	- colorspace runs intersect on the two caps.
	- if the intersection is NULL, colorspace has to set up a conversion function.
	- runs through the list of caps, picking the first one for which a
	converter exists between the received caps and the target caps. set up
	the converter and set the target caps on the srcpad.
	- if the intersection is not NULL, set received caps on colorspace srcpad.


	use case 3
	----------

	mpeg2dec -> queue -> colorspace -> queue -> xvideosink


	Same as use case 2, really. the queue just forwards the caps and the
	request caps.

	can we use a default implementation for this proxying? probably.
	for an element with no newcaps function or request_caps function, we can
	simply set the caps on all srcpads when a set_caps is performed, or we
	can request and intersect all srcpad caps when a peer element does
	request_caps. This will actually work for tee too, to some degree.


	use case 4
	----------

	gst_pad_connect_caps (...),
	gst_element_connect_caps (v4lsrc, "src", xvideosink, "sink",
	GST_CAPS_NEW (
	"app_caps",
	"video/raw",
	"format", GST_PROPS_FOURCC (GST_STR_FOURCC ("I420")),
	"width", GST_PROPS_INT (352),
	"height", GST_PROPS_INT (288)
	)
	);

	- as long as the connection is not broken, the caps are set as a filter to the
	to pads.

	- when v4lsrc requests pads, the intersection with the filter is also made.

	- v4lsrc has no other choice but to use I420.

	use case 5
	----------

	mad -> osssink

	in this case, mad can both send "int" audio samples and "float" samples.

	- mad request_caps from osssink, sending the fixed properties as hints (rate,
	channels, ...)
	- osssink has a request_caps function, the core first makes the intersection
	between the hint and mad srcpad template. the core then does the intersection
	between osssink sinkpad template and sends this list to osssinks request_caps
	function. osssink can try this list (or whatever remains of it) and whatever
	works is sent back as the return value of the request_caps function.
	- mad receives the caps list, takes the top caps and does a pad_set_caps
	- osssink recieves the final caps on its new_caps function and configures the
	oss driver.


	use case 6
	----------

	gsm -> audioscaler -> osssink

	Somebody sets some crazy low rate on the gsm srcpad (1000Hz).

	- audioscalers newcaps function is called.
	- audioscaler does a request_caps on its srcpad with the provided
	caps as a hint.
	- osssink tries the caps in the request_caps function (by opening the
	device, seeing that it doesn't support this rate at all...)
	- osssink tries to comply as closely with the rate and sends the
	intersection between its padtemplate caps and the findings (rate 8000Hz
	is possible).
	- audioscaler does the intersection between the caps list and the hint.
	- intersection == NULL, a converter is needed between the hint and
	the first caps of the request_caps list.
	- intersection != NULL, set those caps (== the hint).